I'm disgusted

[Millane]

Why, just because he has long hair and is nervous about fighting in his first battle? I can think of plenty of men that would get nervous in that situation, too!

well yeah the long hair sorta does give off the girlish appearence. nervous he should have taken a lesson off those berzerkers and got himself hyped up.

[Nurvingiel]

Originally posted by Millane
ummm no in the book Legolas translates and says to sam "they say you breathe so loudly they could shoot you in the dark" in the movie Haldir says it and gimli should have tought him some respect with his axe...

More than likely, you are right. It doesn't matter that I don't remember this particular quote word for word (or even who said it .)

The point is, then intent of the quote is still there. It's nice to see liasons between the book and the movie, even if they are slightly altered.

[Gaporli]

I was sad that Haldir was killed off, but at least he died bravely.

[forest_flower]

HALDIR LIVES!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

i could strangle p. jackson for killing him-craig parker does a lousy job, SO! he's still haldir!!!!!!!!!

haldir lives through SO many battles, why must he die BEFORE gandalf comes, it's insulting

i have a HUGE mental list of people responsible for his death, in and (hint, hint) in charge of the movie

also, haldir's NOT rude he's just VERY arrogant (and it's amusing)

*i'm sorry but reading all that made me v. mad, i could blabber on and on all day about that topic, AND his death*

[Gamigar]