Arwen

I don't think Liv Tyler is beautiful enough to be Arwen Undomiel. My brother and I downloaded the trailer, and when Arwen came on my brother said, "Legolas!"

Gene Tierney circa 1944-45 would've been almost right -- darkhaired, grey-eyed, pale, a remote and almost catlike beauty. Very stunningly gorgeous in _Leave Her to Heaven_ (1945).

There aren't any Gene Tierneys around nowadays, least they aren't working in the movies. Still, I imagine PJ could've done a lot better than Ms. Tyler.