When does Cirdan leave ME?

Telcontar87 · 08-19-2011, 11:24 AM

IÂ´m inclined to think that either he left with Gandalf and company, or just a bit later (but not much later)

With Sauron being defeated (last Enemy of elves and men), his foresight would not be of much avail to anyone anymore. And since he wasnÂ´t appointed any task in particular (by that time all elves could build their own boats and find the straight path) he must have felt free to go at last.

As for Sam, IÂ´m not sure he needed CÃ*rdanÂ´s help more than he could have used any other elven shipbuilderÂ´s help in those days.

Similar Threads
Thread	Thread Starter	Forum	Replies	Last Post
I want some people to go over some of my writing	Amea	Writer's Workshop	24	12-09-2003 12:03 PM
Why did the elves leave Middle Earth?	Lief Erikson	Lord of the Rings Books	23	03-06-2003 06:38 PM
zits; leave 'em, squeeze 'em?	Laurenis	General Messages	5	03-23-2002 06:58 PM
Happy Birthday Cirdan	Arathorn	General Messages	8	03-16-2002 12:23 AM
Cirdan the Shipwright...had a beard...	Captain Stern	Lord of the Rings Books	12	07-24-2001 11:06 PM

08-19-2011, 11:24 AM	#21
Telcontar87 Sapling Join Date: Jul 2009 Location: Spain Posts: 5	IÂ´m inclined to think that either he left with Gandalf and company, or just a bit later (but not much later) With Sauron being defeated (last Enemy of elves and men), his foresight would not be of much avail to anyone anymore. And since he wasnÂ´t appointed any task in particular (by that time all elves could build their own boats and find the straight path) he must have felt free to go at last. As for Sam, IÂ´m not sure he needed CÃ*rdanÂ´s help more than he could have used any other elven shipbuilderÂ´s help in those days.