Concerning Hobbits

[Gwaimir Windgem]

Actually, it doesn't make sense.

[Elvengirl]

Originally posted by Dúnedain

Pip = I like Pip too, I think in Fellowship you get to see his more juvenile side and then in TTT I think you see him "coming of age" a bit. Although some might not agree, the whole Ent thing when Pip gets Treebeard to go to Isengard, because he knows it will get the Ents involved, I liked. At first I didn't, because I wanted it done at the Entmoot like in the book, however it makes great sense the way it was done in the movie, because it shows the true strengths of Pip coming out and growing up...

I didn't like how Pippin had to show Trebeard what was happening at Isengaurd. Why wouldn't he know what is happening in his own forest?

But I do like Pippin and how he does grow up.