Discussion for 'Demaethor and Amariel'

[Rosie Gamgee]

Originally Posted by Valandil

Rosie - your completion of what Beor and I started so long ago really more than does us credit - much more! You've done a great job with it. Thank you.

So I didn't ruin/railroad it. Oh, good! Anyway, don't thank me. I have had all kinds of fun doing it, and almost no writer's block (which is amazing for me). You're welcome.

Will the epilogue be similar to the one I suggested to you that once? Or have you improved much on that also?

Similar, and a bit expanded... I have this insatiable need to see all the way to the end. And I had this hankering to attach Amariel to the line of Findulias, the wife of Denethor. But I think that's too much work. We'll see.

Originally Posted by Eärniel

Nice touch with the battle axe, I hadn't seen that coming, but I like it. Much more original than just rings.

Thanks. I had all these objects and phrases that I kind of used here and there in important places. One was the cloak of Demaethor, but I lost it in Elendil's house. So I decided to use the axe.. I'm so glad it works.