Orlando and co in a band!!!

[CloudyRose]

I'd say the Fellowship would be a prog rock vocal tag team and have something like this:

Sean Astin mainly on drums, but may be on keyboards or guitar while singing

Sean Bean on either bass or rhythm guitar depending on the song

Orlando Bloom on either bass or lead guitar

Billy Boyd on guitar, bass or drums depending on the song

Ian McKellen on... maybe anything as long as it fits the song?

Dominic Monaghan on rhythm guitar and sometimes keyboards

Viggo Mortensen on keyboards, though can sometimes play harmonica

John Rhys-Davies on either a flute or harmonica, otherwise it would be a tambourine (think Ray Thomas)

Elijah Wood on lead guitar, and sometimes rhythm guitar depending on the song