Do you think Middle Earth became our earth?

Alas, no. And if you can't find out, I don't think anyone can. I assume you have tried to research the web for the answer?

Wow Hernalt, you certainly have strong feelings about this topic!

(Hernalt is suddenly embarrassed that he let Tolkien affect his personal life, and hides his face for shame...)

Shame, embarrassment?!! From where I sit, it seems that Tolkien is inseparatable from your life, not merely affecting it. I look forward to your insightful posts on this forum.....and you better keep it up!!

Yes, Hernalt, we like your info, and who can help but get emotional about our middle earth? Did you mention somewhere that you have a website for this kind of stuff? Just for an obvious answer, at the beginning of the Hobbit, isn't there something about hobbits still existing, but they're small and quiet so we don't notice them? I don't have my books, so I'm probably wrong. shrug. Elanor the golden flower

NO.

Of course you over looked the obvious.....it just might all be real! Ah, Elbereth Githoneil.

~ Hernalt and others set a feast to welcome the lost Elves of the Stars ~

Yeah i do. (look at subject) Theres some charts in one of those books Christopher Tolkien organized(shaping of middle earth) and its really quite obvious. Do you realize that Valinor is America?!

i guess it could be. but do you realize that the length of these posts proves the fact that we have no life, a fact i am d@mn proud of!

Yep, Middle Earth became Europe, and Valinor became America. I really shouldn't be telling you this, but I am really Manwe in disguise (we can take different forms, you know). I can't let ordinary mortals know that, so keep it down, okay?

[ranger]

i say we burn everything walt disney created and transform this world into middle earth

i am a ranger.... i will fight for right and what i believe( you insult my family, friends hobbies.......i will fight for it even if i will not survive) aragorn (viggo) rocks!